
Unlike ordinary jobs, where one is promoted based on their job performance and their perceived ability to perform in the higher tier position, the Army has the most ridiculously bureaucratic process for promotion from Specialist to Sergeant. No matter what your job in the Army is, you have to appear in front of a board of senior enlisted personnel and answer a series of ridiculous questions. If you're a medic, don't expect any medical questions that would actually reveal your competence at your job - expect questions like "Which Army Regulation deals with the Army Weight Control Program?" or "What is the effective range of an M4 Carbine?" The especially ridiculous ones will ask what year the Army standardized NCO training schools Armywide, or which President established the Code of Conduct. Seriously, go to
armystudyguide.com to see the study topics and sample questions that every specialist may be asked at their promotion board. Remember that these questions are asked of all soldiers, whether lab technician, infantry, finance clerk, or mechanic. So basically your inability to spew random Army regulation or Field Manual numbers (a skill completely useless in the age of Google) Also, it's not enough to answer the questions correctly - you must have a certain confidence and professionalism to your manner of answering these questions. They'll also make you do drill and ceremony facing movements, and occasionally will play games with you. I'm told by several NCO's that it's pretty common to ask a ridiculous question like "How many steps are on the stairwell in this building?" or "How many tiles are in your platoon sergeant's office?" The idea is for the person trying to get promoted to answer with some bullshit answer, full of confidence. Uh, I'm not an expert on human resources management, but it seems to me that this really isn't a skill worth emphasizing in the promotion process.
The best part of all this, is that to even go to the board you have to get the approval of your platoon sergeant and your commander. And then there are the whole time in service/time in grade requirements. Finally, just because you pass all these requirements doesn't mean you have enough promotion points to get promoted. Promotion points vary from job to job, so some people don't have trouble with this last hoop. But there are 5 hoops you have to jump through, and any of these hoops have veto power over your promotion. This leads to wildly inconsistent standards on who makes promotion from unit to unit (every board is different, and different platoon sergeants and commanders have different standards) and job to job (promotion points).
Photo by Flickr user ob1left and used under a Creative Commons License.